Why Do Retail Investors Always Lose in the US Stock Market After-Hours Trading?
Open your trading software and watch the fluctuating quotes of the US stock market after-hours. Have you ever felt confused—why do the prices of the same stocks differ so much between after-hours and regular trading hours? Why do some say electronic trading “looks active but is actually a trap”?
The truth is, US stock market after-hours trading is not a paradise for retail investors but a battleground for institutional investors. However, if you understand the rules and risks involved, you can actually leverage them to your advantage.
The Real Face of US Stock Market After-Hours Trading: Advantages and Traps
Why is after-hours trading attractive to investors?
Electronic trading (after-hours) breaks through the limitations of traditional trading hours. The normal trading hours for US stocks are from 9:30 AM to 4:00 PM Eastern Time, but after-hours trading extends until 8:00 PM ET. This means that after the release of overnight news, investors can immediately position themselves in the night session without waiting for the next day’s open.
Futures electronic trading is even more flexible—crude oil, gold, various index futures are traded almost 24 hours a day, allowing global investors to participate at any time and respond promptly to market changes.
Risks are much greater than you think
However, opportunities often come with risks. In after-hours trading, the following three major risks can directly impact your returns:
1. Liquidity dries up, spreads are shocking
Fewer participants in after-hours trading compared to regular hours lead to significantly wider bid-ask spreads. Do you want to execute at a specific price? During the night session, you might find no counterpart. Some stocks may even have no trades for extended periods, forming a “dead zone.”
The after-hours period is prone to major news releases—corporate earnings reports, economic data, geopolitical events. These sudden pieces of information can trigger intense volatility at the next open, potentially reversing your overnight positions entirely.
3. Large institutions crush retail investors
Institutional investors possess more comprehensive information and stronger pricing power. In the “less crowded” night session, they can better exploit their advantages. Retail investors often find themselves in a passive position.
Detailed Explanation of US Stock Market After-Hours Trading Times: A Must-Read for Taiwanese Investors
To participate in US after-hours trading, first understand the time zone conversions.
US stock after-hours trading times and corresponding Taiwan time:
Trading Session
US Eastern Time
Taiwan Time (Daylight Saving)
Taiwan Time (Standard)
Pre-market
04:00-09:30
16:00-21:30
17:00-22:30
Regular hours
09:30-16:00
21:30-04:00
22:30-05:00
After-hours (Night session)
16:00-20:00
04:00-08:00
05:00-09:00
If Taiwanese investors trade US stock after-hours during winter time, they need to operate between 5:00 AM and 9:00 AM. Note that the US observes Daylight Saving Time (second Sunday in March to first Sunday in November) and Standard Time (first Sunday in November to second Sunday in March), with a one-hour difference.
US Futures Electronic Trading: The 24-Hour “All-Weather Battlefield”
Compared to stock after-hours, futures electronic trading has longer hours and better liquidity.
US futures electronic trading schedule (using stock index futures as an example):
Trading Session
US Eastern Time
Taiwan Time (Daylight Saving)
Taiwan Time (Standard)
Manual trading
09:30-16:15
21:30-04:15
22:30-05:15
Electronic (night session)
16:30-09:15
04:30-21:15
05:30-22:15
Note: Electronic trading on Mondays starts 1.5 hours later.
Through futures, investors can trade a variety of commodities like crude oil, gold, S&P 500 futures, etc. Although participation in electronic futures trading is higher than in stock night trading, caution is still needed due to overnight gap risks.
Comparison of Taiwan Futures Night Session and US Electronic Trading
Want to trade locally? Since 2017, Taiwan Futures Exchange has offered after-hours trading for products like TAIEX futures.
Taiwan futures trading hours:
Trading Session
Index Futures
Currency Futures
Day session
08:45-13:45
08:45-16:15
Night session (Electronic)
15:00-05:00
17:25-05:00
Compared to US futures electronic trading, Taiwan’s night session is shorter, but the advantage is friendly time zones—Taiwan investors don’t need to stay up late.
How to Check US Stock After-Hours and Futures Electronic Quotes?
Stock Night Quote Inquiry
Nasdaq’s official website directly provides after-hours trading quotes. Visit the “After-Hours Trading” page to see real-time quotes of popular stocks like Tesla. Many brokerage platforms (such as Interactive Brokers) also offer electronic trading quote functions.
Futures Electronic Quote Inquiry
CME official website and TradingView are mainstream options for checking US futures electronic quotes. The latter is known for its charting features and real-time data, suitable for technical analysis enthusiasts.
Note: Different trading platforms may show slight discrepancies in quotes due to delays, liquidity differences, etc. Investors should verify that their quote sources are reliable.
5 Practical Tips for US Stock Market After-Hours Trading
1. Limit orders are standard; market orders may not execute
US stock after-hours trading only accepts limit orders. Investors must set their buy or sell prices themselves. If the after-hours quote is far from your limit price, your order may remain unfilled all night.
2. Spread differences cause hidden costs
Prices of the same stock can vary across platforms during after-hours. Choosing the wrong platform might cost you extra fees or reduce profits. It’s recommended to compare multiple data sources before trading.
3. Beware of overnight gaps
Any geopolitical or economic news from after-hours to the next day’s open can cause sharp swings. Weekends are even riskier—holding positions overnight until Monday’s open increases the risk exponentially.
4. Institutional players dominate during certain periods, retail investors should be cautious
The night session is mainly driven by institutional investors and block traders. Their actions can create false breakouts, luring retail investors to follow and then reversing to trap them.
5. Understanding platform trading rules is crucial
Different platforms have different rules for night trading (such as minimum order size, allowed order types, etc.). Always read the relevant instructions carefully before trading.
When should you participate in US stock after-hours trading? When should you avoid it?
Advantages of after-hours trading
After major news releases: Companies releasing earnings or significant news after hours can give early opportunities to position
Global market linkage: When European or Asian markets are volatile, US after-hours often reacts in advance
Technical breakouts: For traders focusing on breakout points, after-hours offers early entry opportunities
Situations to avoid
Low liquidity stocks: Stocks with already thin trading volume are even harder to trade after hours
Before major economic data releases: If significant data is scheduled within the next 12 hours, overnight risks are high
When you cannot monitor the market continuously: Rapid after-hours changes can lead to severe losses if you cannot respond promptly
Final Advice: Rational View of US Stock Market After-Hours Trading
The emergence of US after-hours and futures electronic trading indeed expands trading time and space. But this is not an invitation to trade frequently; rather, it’s a tool for early positioning under specific circumstances.
Retail investors should:
Fully understand liquidity risks and price volatility
Not be fooled by the hype of “24-hour trading opportunities”
Only participate cautiously after understanding the trading rules
Always prioritize risk management
Remember, being able to trade does not mean you should trade. The key to surviving in US stock after-hours trading is knowing when to act and when to hold back.
View Original
This page may contain third-party content, which is provided for information purposes only (not representations/warranties) and should not be considered as an endorsement of its views by Gate, nor as financial or professional advice. See Disclaimer for details.
Complete Guide to US Stock Market After-Hours Trading: Understand After-Hours Trading Times and Risk Warnings
Why Do Retail Investors Always Lose in the US Stock Market After-Hours Trading?
Open your trading software and watch the fluctuating quotes of the US stock market after-hours. Have you ever felt confused—why do the prices of the same stocks differ so much between after-hours and regular trading hours? Why do some say electronic trading “looks active but is actually a trap”?
The truth is, US stock market after-hours trading is not a paradise for retail investors but a battleground for institutional investors. However, if you understand the rules and risks involved, you can actually leverage them to your advantage.
The Real Face of US Stock Market After-Hours Trading: Advantages and Traps
Why is after-hours trading attractive to investors?
Electronic trading (after-hours) breaks through the limitations of traditional trading hours. The normal trading hours for US stocks are from 9:30 AM to 4:00 PM Eastern Time, but after-hours trading extends until 8:00 PM ET. This means that after the release of overnight news, investors can immediately position themselves in the night session without waiting for the next day’s open.
Futures electronic trading is even more flexible—crude oil, gold, various index futures are traded almost 24 hours a day, allowing global investors to participate at any time and respond promptly to market changes.
Risks are much greater than you think
However, opportunities often come with risks. In after-hours trading, the following three major risks can directly impact your returns:
1. Liquidity dries up, spreads are shocking
Fewer participants in after-hours trading compared to regular hours lead to significantly wider bid-ask spreads. Do you want to execute at a specific price? During the night session, you might find no counterpart. Some stocks may even have no trades for extended periods, forming a “dead zone.”
2. Price volatility amplifies, overnight risks suddenly emerge
The after-hours period is prone to major news releases—corporate earnings reports, economic data, geopolitical events. These sudden pieces of information can trigger intense volatility at the next open, potentially reversing your overnight positions entirely.
3. Large institutions crush retail investors
Institutional investors possess more comprehensive information and stronger pricing power. In the “less crowded” night session, they can better exploit their advantages. Retail investors often find themselves in a passive position.
Detailed Explanation of US Stock Market After-Hours Trading Times: A Must-Read for Taiwanese Investors
To participate in US after-hours trading, first understand the time zone conversions.
US stock after-hours trading times and corresponding Taiwan time:
If Taiwanese investors trade US stock after-hours during winter time, they need to operate between 5:00 AM and 9:00 AM. Note that the US observes Daylight Saving Time (second Sunday in March to first Sunday in November) and Standard Time (first Sunday in November to second Sunday in March), with a one-hour difference.
US Futures Electronic Trading: The 24-Hour “All-Weather Battlefield”
Compared to stock after-hours, futures electronic trading has longer hours and better liquidity.
US futures electronic trading schedule (using stock index futures as an example):
Note: Electronic trading on Mondays starts 1.5 hours later.
Through futures, investors can trade a variety of commodities like crude oil, gold, S&P 500 futures, etc. Although participation in electronic futures trading is higher than in stock night trading, caution is still needed due to overnight gap risks.
Comparison of Taiwan Futures Night Session and US Electronic Trading
Want to trade locally? Since 2017, Taiwan Futures Exchange has offered after-hours trading for products like TAIEX futures.
Taiwan futures trading hours:
Compared to US futures electronic trading, Taiwan’s night session is shorter, but the advantage is friendly time zones—Taiwan investors don’t need to stay up late.
How to Check US Stock After-Hours and Futures Electronic Quotes?
Stock Night Quote Inquiry
Nasdaq’s official website directly provides after-hours trading quotes. Visit the “After-Hours Trading” page to see real-time quotes of popular stocks like Tesla. Many brokerage platforms (such as Interactive Brokers) also offer electronic trading quote functions.
Futures Electronic Quote Inquiry
CME official website and TradingView are mainstream options for checking US futures electronic quotes. The latter is known for its charting features and real-time data, suitable for technical analysis enthusiasts.
Note: Different trading platforms may show slight discrepancies in quotes due to delays, liquidity differences, etc. Investors should verify that their quote sources are reliable.
5 Practical Tips for US Stock Market After-Hours Trading
1. Limit orders are standard; market orders may not execute
US stock after-hours trading only accepts limit orders. Investors must set their buy or sell prices themselves. If the after-hours quote is far from your limit price, your order may remain unfilled all night.
2. Spread differences cause hidden costs
Prices of the same stock can vary across platforms during after-hours. Choosing the wrong platform might cost you extra fees or reduce profits. It’s recommended to compare multiple data sources before trading.
3. Beware of overnight gaps
Any geopolitical or economic news from after-hours to the next day’s open can cause sharp swings. Weekends are even riskier—holding positions overnight until Monday’s open increases the risk exponentially.
4. Institutional players dominate during certain periods, retail investors should be cautious
The night session is mainly driven by institutional investors and block traders. Their actions can create false breakouts, luring retail investors to follow and then reversing to trap them.
5. Understanding platform trading rules is crucial
Different platforms have different rules for night trading (such as minimum order size, allowed order types, etc.). Always read the relevant instructions carefully before trading.
When should you participate in US stock after-hours trading? When should you avoid it?
Advantages of after-hours trading
Situations to avoid
Final Advice: Rational View of US Stock Market After-Hours Trading
The emergence of US after-hours and futures electronic trading indeed expands trading time and space. But this is not an invitation to trade frequently; rather, it’s a tool for early positioning under specific circumstances.
Retail investors should:
Remember, being able to trade does not mean you should trade. The key to surviving in US stock after-hours trading is knowing when to act and when to hold back.